Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, but ideally 24 hours. Mittie’s always made her chicken salad the day before service. The flavors need time to marry, and the almond extract will mellow from “perfume” to “what is that lovely note?”
For nearly seven decades, Mittie’s was more than a restaurant. It was a gentle institution—a hushed sanctuary of floral wallpaper, silver teapots, and the quiet clink of spoons on china. And at the heart of its menu was a chicken salad so ethereal, so perfectly balanced, that former patrons still speak of it in reverent whispers, long after the tea room’s final service. mittie-s tea room chicken salad recipe
Here’s where things get interesting. Many longtime patrons swear that Mittie’s chicken salad contained a whisper of almond extract. Not enough to taste as “almond,” but enough to elevate the chicken’s natural flavor. Others insist it was a tiny amount of finely ground blanched almonds folded in at the end. Either way, that nutty, floral undertone was the key. Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours,
Celery is standard, but Mittie’s minced it almost to a brunoise—tiny, uniform cubes. This gave a delicate crunch without the aggressive, vegetal bite that can overwhelm. Some former employees have hinted that the celery was briefly soaked in ice water to crisp it further before mincing. It was a gentle institution—a hushed sanctuary of
Mittie herself was known for her starched aprons, her warm but no-nonsense demeanor, and her unerring palate. The tea room originally served light lunches and afternoon tea to ladies who “shopped downtown.” But word quickly spread: the chicken salad was something special.
You’ll taste it then—the ghost of Mittie’s. The perfect crunch of celery. The faint, floral almond note. The tender chicken. And for just a moment, a little bit of old Louisville comes back to the table. If you make this recipe, share it with someone who remembers Mittie’s. And if you’re enjoying it for the first time, consider yourself initiated into a quiet Southern tradition—one chicken salad sandwich at a time.
In a medium bowl, combine mayonnaise, drained relish, minced onion, sugar, celery salt, almond extract, and white pepper. Mash the hard-boiled egg yolks into this mixture with a fork until smooth and pale yellow. Set aside.